Category Archives: Chandre Prince

Let them drink Valpré says Ficksburg mayor

http://www.timeslive.co.za/specialreports/elections2011/article1028697.ece/Let-them-drink-Valpr-eacute–says-Ficksburg-mayor

Let them drink Valpré says Ficksburg mayor

Residents’ anger boils over at Tatane court case
Apr 18, 2011 10:24 PM | By SIPHO MASONDO in Ficksburg

“People say there is no water in this town. What is this?” giggled Ficksburg’s mayor, Mbothoma Maduna, reaching into his office fridge for bottles of Valpré mineral water.

Maduna’s words came minutes before six policemen appeared in the Ficksburg Magistrate’s Court, a stone’s throw from his office, in connection with the death of Andries Tatane, killed during a protest against the town’s crippling water shortages.

On Wednesday, Tatane was allegedly shot twice at close range with rubber bullets, and beaten with batons, by a group of police officers in an attack shown nationwide on SABC TV news.

He and residents of the nearby township of Maqheleng had marched to the Setsoto municipal offices to demand a reliable supply of water and an immediate halt to the daily sewage spills into roads and gardens in the township.

A postmortem examination has found that Tatane died from gunshot wounds. The examiner’s report will be completed in a few weeks.

The Times has learned that a number of Independent Complaints Directorate officials were present at the examination by the Bloemfontein district surgeon.

ICD spokesman Moses Dlamini said the investigation into Tatane’s death might be finalised by the end of this week.

Investigators interviewed 14 policemen and arrested six of them.

The trial of Olebogeng Mphirime, Tehedi Moeketsie, Jonas Skosana, and Mphonyane Ntaje, who face charges of serious assault, and of Israel Moiloa and Mothusi Magano, charged with murder, was postponed to April 26, when they are expected to apply for bail.

Dlamini said more arrests might follow.

Tatane’s widow, Rose, and a relative of one of the six accused almost came to blows in court yesterday.

After the female relative entered the packed courtroom and demanded seats for the accused’s family, Rose Tatane shouted: “Shut up! Shut up! Do you not care that we have lost a person? The only thing you care about is sitting space for your people.

“Do you know that we could very well ask the mob [of protestors outside] to attack you when we leave this place?

“I wish I had a gun. I was going to kill them all [the accused] when they come inside!”

A court orderly asked the other woman to leave.

The six policemen came into the court wearing hats, hooded tops and woollen caps drawn over their eyes to prevent them being identified.

They were remanded in custody and will return to court on Tuesday next week for their bail hearing.

As they walked out of the court, Rose Tatane shouted: “These are not police, they are thugs!”

Outside the court, a group of about 500 protesters sang, whistled and waved placards, demanding that immediate action be taken against the alleged killers.

“No bail! No bail! No bail!” they chanted. Some of their placards read: “Protect us, don’t kill us”, “Rot in jail”, “Shoot to kill” and “Cele do your job”.

Others waved placards showing newspaper pictures of the police attacking Tatane, blood flowing from his chest, and collapsing.

“Somebody hold us, we will kill these dogs,” the crowd shouted, charging towards a group of grim-faced policemen inside the court’s yard, safely behind locked gates.

Facing the municipal building, they sang: “We don’t have water, sewage is stinking and it’s rotten. What have we done? Why are the police killing us? Why did they kill Tatane? He was fighting for our rights.”

Tsheliso Mpekoa, a local businessman who organised the march during which Tatane was killed, said the residents will not back down in their calls for Maduna, his senior managers and his councillors to resign.

He said that the municipality was riddled with corruption.

“We are meeting the co-operative governance MEC, Mamiki Qabathe, on Thursday. The municipality should be placed under administration. There should be an investigation and those who have to be dismissed should be dismissed.”

But Maduna insisted his administration was clean.

“It’s a perception and it’s not enough to make conclusions that we are failing to deal with corruption.

“If this office is made aware of such acts we will be able to act. If people see incomplete projects, they conclude it’s corruption.”

Dawood Adam, a senior official of the National Prosecuting Authority, told journalists that the director of the NPA, Menzi Simelane “sends his deepest condolences and calls for calm”. – Additional reporting by Chandre Prince

The Times: Protester beaten and shot to death

http://www.timeslive.co.za/specialreports/elections2011/article1019541.ece/Protester-beaten-and-shot-to-death

Protester beaten and shot to death

Shocking images as police shown beating defenceless protester to death

Apr 13, 2011 10:19 PM | By CHANDRE PRINCE, SIPHO MASONDO and HARRIET MCLEA
Shocking images of police brutality were broadcast to the nation on television yesterday – they showed an unarmed man being beaten to death by a mob of policemen.

Pictures of the attack on the 33-year-old man by at least six policemen simultaneously, during a service delivery protest at Setsoto, in Ficksburg, eastern Free State, were shown on all SABC news bulletins last night.

The visuals show how the armed policemen cornered Andries Tatane, striking him with their batons and kicking him in an assault that lasted for a few minutes.

Tatane, from Masaleng township, Ficksburg, is seen holding his hand against his chest after the assault. He collapsed about 20 minutes later and died before an ambulance arrived.

As well as being beaten, he had been shot twice.

Last night Tatane’s brother, Lefu Tatane, told The Times of the “shocking murder” of his elder brother.

“We are very angry. I can’t even describe it. He was no danger to the police or anyone. Why did they have to kill him?” said Lefu.

Tatane was part of a group of about 4000 protesters who marched to the Setsoto municipal offices yesterday morning demanding a response to a memorandum of demands they had sent to the mayor, Mbothoma Maduna, and the municipal manager, Bafana Mthembu.

The people of Setsoto, like many others across the country, are fed-up with the lack of services in their area and demanded that Maduna and Mthembu speed up their provision.

According to Lefu, the demonstration had been peaceful until a rock was thrown into the crowd of protesters.

Police reinforcements were called in and, according to at least two eyewitnesses, chaos erupted when police water cannon were used against the protesters.

One eyewitness said that Tatane had jumped in front of an elderly man who was being sprayed by the water cannon.

“The only thing he did was to ask that they not spray the old man and then all hell broke loose. The next minute, police were all over Tatane. He was defenceless.”

According to his brother, Tatane sustained two bullet wounds, one to the chest and one in the back.

But the police claim that they were trying to arrest Tatane. They said they did not know who shot him.

Police spokesman Captain Phumelelo Dlamini said: “They were trying to arrest him. While he was being arrested, there was a gun shot so we don’t know who shot him but we’re going to investigate.”

Police also shot at the crowd, which, after witnessing the beating of Tatane, turned violent.

A number of witnesses said it was the police that shot Tatane.

Last night, Lefu said his brother’s wife was too distraught to talk and the family was taking her for medical treatment.

Tatane is also survived by a three-year-old child.

Maduna, the mayor of Setsoto, said: “It’s really unfortunate to have a person dying as a result [of the protests]. We regret it . it was not supposed to have happened. We will contribute towards the burial and show that we care.”

Free State Premier Ace Magashule said: “We will sit down and talk and work together [with the people of Setsoto]. We are sending condolences to the family.

Lefu said officials of the Independant Complaints Directorate visited the family home at about 3pm yesterday and would return today.

The ANC last night condemned the killing and called on Police Minister Nathi Mthethwa to set up a commission of inquiry

ANC spokesman Jackson Mthembu said the police responsible for the killing should be brought to book.

“We are shocked and disgusted by what we saw on television. No reason can be raised about the behaviour of the police.

“Our people have a constitutional right to protest and the action by the police is reminiscent of the apartheid police force,” Mthembu said.

David Bruce, senior a researcher at The Centre for the Study of Violence and Reconciliation, said that there had been an increase in the number of people killed by the police in recent years.

The peak year was 2008-2009.

ICD statistics show a steady increase in complaints of serious non-fatal police violence, assault with intent to commit grievous bodily harm and attempted murder.