Category Archives: Karabo Keepile

M&G: ‘There is no human who can sleep in this’

Click here to see a slideshow on this eviction and its aftermath.

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2010-10-18-there-is-no-human-who-can-sleep-in-this

‘There is no human who can sleep in this’
KARABO KEEPILE | JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – Oct 18 2010 15:30

Evicted shack dwellers from the Gabon informal settlement on the East Rand have refused to occupy the 72 corrugated iron shacks built for them by the Ekurhuleni Municipality. This after they were evicted and their shacks demolished on May 11.

According to community members, “Red Ants [security guards known for the colour of their overalls] destroyed about 350 shacks on the day”.

However, only 72 evicted community members gathered outside Constitutional Hill in July to seek legal representation, since many of the other evicted residents intimidated by the police had fled the area.

According to Reghana Tulk — the lawyer representing the evicted community members — evicted residents received unaddressed notices 24 hours prior to their evictions.

However, evicted residents that the Mail & Guardian spoke to denied receiving such notice.

Many claimed they were not home when the demolitions took place and had received no earlier warning. Many also said their belongings had either been destroyed or misplaced during the demolitions.

One resident, Moses Mahlalela, said his TV had been damaged while his generator and blankets had been stolen.

Settlement agreement

In accordance with a settlement agreement handed down on August 10 by the South Gauteng High Court, the evictions and demolitions were found to be unlawful.

As a result, the municipality was ordered to rebuild 72 shacks of the people who sought legal recourse.

According to Reghana Tulk — the lawyer representing the evicted community members — all parties involved agreed on a show house, which was represented as a sample of the 72 units to be constructed, and became the agreed standard as to what would constitute restitution as ordered by the court on August 30.

“We agreed on single metal sheets, wooden beams in the ceiling, about 16m², two windows and a door,” Tulk told the M&G.

However, on her first inspection visit on September 6, she realised that what had been agreed upon had not been complied with.

According to Tulk, all of the 72 units did not conform with the show house, and are not stable — they have not been constructed from single metal sheets but rather from second-hand, rusted cut metal, “which has been haphazardly joined together by old and rusted bolts”.

In addition, there are no stable wooden beams holding up the roof of each unit, representing a safety concern.

Evicted residents have since refused to occupy the shacks, saying they are poorly built, incomplete and dangerous to live in. Many of these people are homeless, sleeping at the homes of neighbours, friends or family members.

‘The shacks they demolished were fine’
Pointing at a shoddily reconstructed shack on October 11, Mfanzile Msibi, chairperson of the Informal Settlement Network, was obviously unimpressed.

“The shacks were supposed to be complete, but as you can see with this one, they are incomplete; there is no door, you look at the window it’s broken, and even the roofs are leaking. Even the floor, it was supposed to be cemented, unlike the condition it is right now. The condition should have been conducive to human life, not like the one that they have built and want to accommodate people.”

Community leader Dumisani Ncapayi No agreed.

“The shacks they demolished were fine. Now they have built structures fit for pigs, because there is no human who can sleep in this.”

According to the municipality, the evicted residents were residing unlawfully at the premises concerned and were evicted without a court order because the structures were half-built and did not constitute homes.

However, many evicted residents said they had been residing on the land for several years, some from as early as 1999.

According to Tulk, the municipality has also contended that the sample unit was a not a show house, despite two other municipal employees confirming with Tulk that the show house was a sample unit of the 72 units to be constructed.

However, this information was only revealed in correspondence to Tulk on September 22, almost a month after the first site inspection.

According to Tulk, evicted Gabon residents won’t take occupation of the current corrugated shacks “until such time as proper restitution is made in accordance with the court order”. Until such time, she says, the municipality is in contempt of court.

M&G: City rebuilds Kliptown shacks after tearing them down

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2010-07-28-city-rebuilds-kliptown-shacks-after-tearing-them-down

City rebuilds Kliptown shacks after tearing them down
KARABO KEEPILE | JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – Jul 28 2010 11:53

Zoleka Ton’s three-year-old daughter, Azile, was inconsolable on June 28 as she watched their shack in Kliptown being torn down by metro police officers.

n’s shack was among eight that were demolished after the Department of Housing’s implementation and monitoring unit accused the shack dwellers of illegally occupying council land in Freedom Charter Square informal settlement.

Letters slipped under the doors of the shacks on June 21 gave the shack dwellers seven days to vacate their dwellings.

The shacks were surrounded by 2 770 other shacks, made of similar material, corrugated iron sheets, wood and other recycled goods.

On July 8, the South Gauteng High Court ordered the city of Johannesburg and the metro police to rebuild the shacks after it ruled that the demolitions and evictions were illegal.

When the Mail & Guardian asked the Department of Housing where it expected the tenants to live after the evictions, the department replied “there must be a place from where they came”.

According to the city, the Department of Housing conducted an audit to determine who should be evicted.

The department claimed some of the evicted residents had families who had been allocated houses in a Reconstruction and Development Programme (RDP) in Pimville Zone 14 and Extension Nine, but they refused to relocate with them.

It also added that it would seek legal recourse “to deal with the other shack dwellers in due course”.

“We cannot condone such [queue jumping] at the disadvantage of people who have been waiting as beneficiaries of that certain project,” Bubu Xuba, from the Department of Housing, told the M&G

The evicted residents disagreed, saying they had been living in the informal settlement for years and many of them had been waiting for RDP houses for just as long.

Thandi Mbatha, for example, claimed she had grown up in Kliptown and had lived there since 1986.

“We came here when I was five. We were fleeing Inkatha [Freedom Party] in Meadowlands and decided to settle here,” she told the M&G.

Violation of Constitution

The court ruled that the evictions took place without a court order and was therefore a violation of the Constitution, which states that “no one may be evicted from their home, or have their home demolished without a court order made after considering all the relevant circumstances”.

The order gave the city and the metro police 14 days to provide the evicted residents with “habitable dwellings that afford [the residents] with shelter, privacy and amenities at least equivalent to those which were destroyed”.

The court also ordered that the shacks be rebuilt on the same sites as the residents’ previous shacks.

The city only started reconstructing the shacks 15 days after the court order, saying there had been “electricity disruptions”.

One day late, on July 23, 10 men in overalls arrived in four trucks loaded with sheets of corrugated iron.

They carried the sheets — fitted with a window and a door — through the narrow spaces between the shacks before placing them on the cement foundations at the sites. Here, they hammered and welded the sheets together before lifting them into position around the foundation.

Zoliswa Mdleleni, who was one of the evicted residents, was the first to have her shack rebuilt, and said it was slightly bigger — at 2,2 square metres — than the original.

Places of privacy

Although the area around Mdleleni’s shack is surrounded by filthy water and dead rats, she is looking forward to moving back.

Marie Huchzermeyer, associate professor at Wits University’s School of Architecture and Planning, said that that as early as the 1830s, when slavery was abolished in the Western Cape, the freed slaves had built their own shacks.

Huchzermeyer said the corrugated iron structures were also homes, places of privacy and comfort to millions of people living in them in South Africa.

M&G: Cape traders to be moved ahead of World Cup

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2010-04-26-cape-traders-to-be-moved-ahead-of-world-cup

Cape traders to be moved ahead of World Cup

KARABO KEEPILE | JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – Apr 26 2010

Street traders at the Grand Parade in Cape Town have been told to leave the area from May 1 until the end of the Soccer World Cup because of Fifa by-laws that relate to host cities.

“According to the host-city agreement, the city is legally obligated to provide a stadium and a fan-fest area,” said Thembinkosi Siganda, Cape Town’s director of economic and human development.

“After a location analysis the city identified the Grand Parade as a fan-fest area and this was approved by Fifa.”

The fan fest, or fan park, was first seen at the World Cup in Germany in 2006. It’s an area in the host city with big screens, music and a place for fans to watch matches for free.

But “there are currently over 300 informal traders operating at the Grand Parade who will be adversely affected” by the development, said Rosheda Muller, chairperson of the Grand Parade Limited Traders’ Association.

The Grand Parade, the main square in Cape Town, is surrounded by the City Hall, the Castle of Good Hope and the Cape Town railway station, and is currently used as a market place and parking area.

Significant investment

But it will soon be transformed into a fan-fest area where the public can view all 64 World Cup matches on a giant high-definition TV screen.

More than 25 000 people are expected to gather at the public viewing area, said Siganda, adding that there had been “significant investment” in infrastructure.

The city plans on spending about R20-million on lighting, landscaping, payments to the event organisers for operating the fan fest and additional parking bays.

“Although traders won’t be able to trade at the Grand Parade, alternative locations have been prepared for them,” said Siganda.

Heated discussions

“The city wanted to put us at Harrington Square but we refused because it is hidden away,” said Muller.

After heated discussions, new sites have been agreed on.

These include the Drill Hall site, Corporation Street, Lower Plain Street and the Castle, and are being prepared to accommodate all 344 permanent traders.

“These sites are in close proximity … not more than 100m away from the Grand Parade,” said Siganda.

New laws

Street traders were operating under a lease agreement with the city and were required to pay a fee of no more than R80 a month — which goes towards security and cleaning — to one of the five trading organisations that operate at the Grand Parade.

The fee is expected to increase when the traders move to the alternative sites, although this is yet to be finalised.

“There have been suggestions that the fee could add up to R20 to R40 a day but we have to check equity fairness,” said Siganda.

“This won’t be a profit-making fee, but will be reasonable because traders are being inconvenienced.”

Grand Parade Traders have now had their trading leases suspended and have received notice that they are not able to trade in the area. There is also talk of introducing a permit for the traders who would be moved.

“I understand that they [the city] need to bind us to some sort of agreement but I reject the permit system, it is like a dompas [apartheid-era pass],” says Riedewaan Charles, vice-chairperson of the Grand Parade Black Pirates Traders’ Association and internal chairperson of the Grand Parade Forum.

He says he will only agree to the permit if it clearly states that it is for the duration of the World Cup and expires after the tournament.

“What about others that want to trade at the Grand Parade after the World Cup, will they be permitted to without a permit?”

“We also want it written that we will be permitted to return back to the Grand Parade after the World Cup.”

Muller commended the city for the manner in which it had been negotiating with the traders in the last two months, but she said street traders were disturbed that they weren’t consulted earlier, since “the city had plans on being a host city a while ago”.

South Africa was awarded the rights to host the soccer tournament, defeating Morocco and Egypt in 2004.

“The mayor of Cape Town, Helen Zille, signed the host-city agreement in 2006 already but the city only engaged with us a couple of months ago,” said Charles.

Job creators

“We are one of the biggest job creators when people are retrenched, without skills or without degrees; we add great value to the country’s economy but we always get the raw deal,” said Muller.

More than 50% of the traders at Grand Parade are Capetonians, while the rest are from Nigeria, Senegal, Angola and Zimbabwe, among other countries, she said.

While street traders have been promised that they will return to normality after the World Cup, Muller said they want changes to be made.

“We only have a month-to-month lease and we would like to renegotiate this with the city. We need security so that we know that we are secured for the future.”

Street traders have been working at the Grand Parade since the 1800s, according to Charles.

M&G: ANC urges calm after Gauteng service-delivery protests

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2010-03-11-anc-urges-calm-after-gauteng-servicedelivery-protests

KARABO KEEPILE | JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – Mar 11 2010 12:34

ANC urges calm after Gauteng service-delivery protests

By mid-morning on Thursday, five metro police cars were lined up on
Impala Road in Dobsonville, Soweto, keeping a watchful eye where
protests had erupted at about 8am.

Taxi marshal Lucky Mokwena told the Mail & Guardian he watched
protesters who had taken to the streets demanding RDP houses hours
earlier: “They were burning tyres and protesting for houses. They say
they have been waiting since 1994.”

Burnt tyres lay scattered at an intersection on Impala Road at 11am on
Thursday. Angry residents — whom the M&G understands were from Zola,
Emdeni and Chiawelo in Soweto — said they would be back the following
day.

Thursday morning’s outburst of community anger over what residents say
is the municipality’s continued failures of service delivery followed
Wednesday’s protests in the same area.

It has been a torrid week of community action in Gauteng. Protests also
flared in:

* Mamelodi and Bronkhorstspruit (on Monday);

* Brits and Oukasie (Tuesday); and

* Reiger Park and Daveyton on the East Rand, Ennerdale
(Johannesburg South), Protea Glen in Soweto, Ramaphosa informal
settlement, Attridgeville and Mamelodi in Pretoria )on Thursday
morning.

On Thursday, the ANC in Gauteng said, “It seems there is a systematic
pattern and that the protests are coordinated with a clear objective to
destabilise government.”

In a statement issued late on Thursday morning, the party appealed “to
communities to remain calm [and] exercise patience and tolerance”.

“The ANC will send a team of leaders to speak to the people about their
concerns and determine appropriate measures to resolve the problems,”
the statement said.

“The protests do not mean that people are disillusioned with the ANC
government, but are raising issues for government to speed up change and
succeed,” the party said in the same statement. — Additional reporting
by Tarryn Harbour and Lisa Steyn

M&G: A mixed masala future

Is this what Cornubia will be like?

http://www.mg.co.za/article/2009-04-28-a-mixed-masala-future

A mixed masala future

KARABO KEEPILE | JOHANNESBURG, SOUTH AFRICA – Apr 28 2009

As the dust settles on a free and fair fourth national election it’s all eyes on the Union Buildings, where President Jacob Zuma will be inaugurated on June 9.What does the future hold? The Mail & Guardian’s team looks at everything from policy changes to taking the pulse of political thinkers across the spectrum. First, take a trip with us to Cosmo City, the future perfect of housing policy. Or is it?

Karabo Keepile takes a surreal trip through Cosmo City

On a recent Thursday afternoon I made my way on foot to Tennessee, by way of Ghana, via the Bahamas. It took me 20 minutes. No cosmic travel, just a stroll through Cosmo City the Gauteng housing department’s “star” mixed development project.

In Cosmo City the street names give away your economic status. The low-income (RDP) houses are in “Africa”, in streets called Tanzania, Swaziland and Luanda. But if you can afford a bonded or semi-bonded house, you can migrate sans passport to the “United States”.

For Housing Minister Lindiwe Sisulu, Cosmo City is more like the New Jerusalem: a symbol of Rainbow Nationhood. Sisulu feels that mixed housing projects like these “dispel the myth that the poor can’t live near the rich”. The housing minister was giving her Angolan counterpart a helicopter tour of Gauteng’s mixed development success stories when she made this remark. “We need to do away with the racially segregated residential areas inherited from the past, so that in future we have residents of South Africa,” she told him.

Back on the ground, I met Ntombifuthi Nyushimani, who is already “a resident of South Africa”. To prove it, she lives in South Africa Drive, where she shares a two-bedroom RDP house with her older sister, Busisiwe, and mother, Gloria. Previously they lived in Zevenfontein informal settlement.

“We live nicely here,” says Nyushimani, briskly rinsing the family washing in a blue bucket outside in the garden. She remembers that there wasn’t much water in Zevenfontein. Or electricity either.

The RDP houses in Cosmo City may all look the same, but people have made them their own. The flowers are watered and the grass is manicured. Some even talk of “extending”, despite the restricted stand size. Over on Ghana Crescent, Khabane Sehlabaka lives with his grandmother. He’s an aspirant musician and his practice sessions can be heard as far away as “Tanzania”. The very same keyboard-playing fingers helped build Cosmo City’s low-income section. This is something Sehlabaka is proud of. “I’m grateful to our government for providing us with shelter and jobs,” he says.

Surprisingly, Sehlabaka doesn’t really object to Cosmo City’s boom gates — which are found everywhere except in the RDP section. “We didn’t buy the RDP houses, so I don’t mind if we don’t have tight security. If I were rich I’d probably want a boom gate too,” he tells me.

CONTINUES BELOW

According to some of Cosmo City’s better-off residents the boom gates are essential for security. Thabile Diseko lives somewhere in the middle of all this, as he rents a room in Extension Seven. He finds mixed housing “confusing”, but is sure of one thing: class segregation is still alive and well. “There’s tension among people in the taxis,” he says.”When someone says ‘I’m getting off at Extension Five’, people who are going to the RDPs look at them funny.”

If Khanyisa Phillips took a taxi, she’d be getting some of the funny looks. Phillips lives on Alabama Street in Extension Five. Here the houses are large and modern. ADT security signs proliferate and DStv is the norm. Phillips says her sister bought the three-bedroom, pastel-coloured house in 2007 and they’ve been living here ever since. “I don’t like this mixed thing, it’s all mixed masala,” she says. Phillips, like many of the residents, complains of burglaries and the lack of shops, clinics and petrol stations. “It’s unfair because we paid a lot for these houses,” she says.

Cecelia Nyasulu used to live in Extension Five. That’s before “they stole everything but my sofas”. Now she lives in Extension Zero. She and her two sons, husband and brother share a cosy two-bedroom house in New Hampshire Street. Her 10-year-old travels all the way to Lanseria every morning, instead of attending Cosmo Primary School, which is close by and free. “In the mornings you’ll see the children outside [the school gates], fighting and just playing around,” Nyasulu says.

But she still prefers to stay in Cosmo City. When she lived in a complex in Fourways “neighbours would complain about noise, because my husband likes to play music”. For Nyasulu, having a house of “her own” is what counts.

In all this cosmic confusion it’s only fair to end with a real American. Chrissy Davies is — actually — from Oregon (no quotation marks needed). The African-American is married to a white South African and they’ve been living in Cosmo City since January. Davies likes it here and, although she’s a newcomer, she is already familiar with the politics. The high-rise walls make her “uncomfortable”, but she understands why they are needed. She doesn’t get the reasoning behind the street names, though, even if they do make her feel like she’s back home. “It just creates division where there could be unity,” she says.

Cosmo City facts

* The city of Johannesburg owns the land where Cosmo City is built.

* Contractors started construction at Cosmo City in February 2005 and the first beneficiaries moved in on November 7 2005.

* Once Cosmo City is complete there will be 12 325 houses, catering for the different income groups.

* Of the 5 000 low-income houses 3 700 have been occupied — these are free RDP houses given to people who meet government criteria.

* There will be a total of 2 965 finance-linked houses (income under R10 000 a month) of which 1 003 are constructed and occupied — these houses are partially subsidised by government, in partnership with the banks.

* The first 281 of the 1 000 rental units should be occupied by October 2009. These are also subsidised by government and, once completed, they will be managed by the Johannesburg Housing Company.

* Of the 3 360 bonded houses (sold on the open market, generally to an income group of plus R20 000/month) 3 021 have been occupied.

* It is anticipated that all the housing units will be complete by the end of 2010.

* Work is under way in areas such as Pennyville — (2 800 housing units), Chief Albert Luthuli Ext 6 (5 389 housing units), Olivenhoutbosch Ext 36 (4 452 units), Thorntree View (17 000 units), Cosmo City (14 800 units), K206 in Alexandra (3 199 units), Doornkop in Soweto (24 100 units), Chief Mogale in Kagiso (9 315 units) and Middelvlei in Mohlakeng (3 495 units).

* In KwaZulu-Natal and Cape Town projects are under way in Blythedale and the N2 Gateway respectively.

* Once planning processes have been completed the department plans to move into areas such as Lady Selbourne (6 000 units), Danville (2 000 units) and Willows (10 977 units).

Keeping house

Property in Cosmo City (approximate prices):

* Two bedroom, two bathroom house: R430 000;

* Three bedroom, two bathroom: between R500 000 and R650 000; and

* Two bedroom, one bathroom: R380 000.