20 November 2026
South Africa, Palestine and the Urgency of Solidarity
South Africa, Palestine and the Urgency of Solidarity
Address at a public meeting hosted by Palestine Solidarity Network Aotearoa at the Ellen Melville Centre in Auckland on Sunday, 8 November 2026.
S’bu Zikode
Comrades, thank you for inviting me to return to Aotearoa. I bring you greetings of solidarity from Abahlali baseMjondolo, the shack dwellers’ movement of South Africa, which was formed in Durban in 2005 and now has more than 200 000 members across South Africa.
It is fifteen years since I was last here, in 2011, when we commemorated the thirtieth anniversary of the great protests against the Springbok rugby tour of 1981. I want to begin by remembering that history, and by thanking all the people of this country who stood with us against apartheid. People marched, confronted the police, and sometimes faced arrest and violence. You refused to allow the apartheid state to present itself as a normal member of the international community.
This was an outstanding example of international solidarity, and an example that we should seek to emulate in our solidarity with the people of Palestine.
In our movement we speak of living solidarity. This means solidarity that exists in action, not just in words. It means solidarity between people who recognise one another as equals.
Settler colonialism in South Africa and Israel
South Africa and Palestine are both countries that have been oppressed by settler colonialism. This is part of the reason for the long solidarity with Palestine among South Africans.
But there are important differences between these two forms of settler colonialism. In South Africa, the colonial system was organised around the dispossession of Africans from their land, the theft of their cattle and the exploitation of their labour. The economy depended on African workers in the mines, on the farms, in the factories and in the homes of white people. The settlers wanted the land, but they also wanted the labour of the people they had dispossessed.
Huge numbers of people were forced from their homes and land as African people were pushed into ‘reserves’, based on the system used to oppress Native Americans, and later into the ‘Bantustans’, the so-called ‘homelands’. The Bantustans were not just used to confine the African people on tiny bits of land. They were also central to the migrant labour system that ensured cheap labour for white capital and for white families in their homes.
African workers were forced by economic necessity to leave their families and communities to find work in the mines and cities. Many were compelled to live in single-sex hostels, separated from their families. Africans were wanted as workers but rejected as citizens with equal rights. They were systematically dehumanised. This system was maintained through the police, the army, prisons, torture and killing. Those who resisted were treated as criminals and terrorists.
When we look at Palestine today, we recognise many of these methods of oppression. We see a fundamentally racist settler colonial system in which there is ongoing dispossession of people from their land by the Israeli state and settlers. We see homes being demolished. We see communities separated from one another by walls, checkpoints and military restrictions. We see people who stand up against oppression being called ‘terrorists’ and subject to mass imprisonment, torture and murder.
The struggles against racism and for land are central to the struggle for freedom, both in South Africa and in Palestine. But there are also differences between apartheid in South Africa and oppression in Palestine.
While Palestinians have been exploited as workers, the fundamental drive of settler colonialism in Israel is to remove or destroy the Palestinian people rather than to exploit them for their labour.
In South Africa, the apartheid system required the continued presence of a large and hyper-exploited African workforce, while seeking to control, segregate and impoverish it. In Palestine, the settler-colonial project has involved the destruction of Palestinian communities, the removal of Palestinians from their land and the attempt to establish and maintain territorial and political control through their displacement.
The Nakba of 1948 forced hundreds of thousands of Palestinians from their homes. Many became refugees in other countries, and they and their descendants remain unable to return. The occupation of the West Bank and East Jerusalem since 1967 has brought further dispossession, settlement expansion and military rule. The genocide in Gaza and the ongoing theft of land in the West Bank have continued the process begun with the Nakba.
We must also recognise that the Palestinian experience has become more terrible in certain respects than the experience of apartheid South Africa. The scale of the destruction of Gaza, the mass displacement and the killing of civilians have horrified people across the world.
There were terrible massacres in apartheid South Africa, most notoriously the massacres at Sharpeville in 1960 and Soweto in 1976. The system of oppression was defended with mass imprisonment, torture and murder and a civil war between Inkatha and the United Democratic Front, between Zulu supremacy and a movement for national liberation. We must also always remember the devastation caused by the apartheid state’s wars and destabilisation of neighbouring countries, including Namibia, Angola and Mozambique.
But we must be clear that, within South Africa itself, the apartheid state did not carry out mass killing on the scale that we have witnessed with the genocide in Gaza. Recognising this difference does not diminish the suffering of South Africans under apartheid.
In South Africa, formal apartheid ended in 1994 when the Black majority finally won the right to vote and the country elected a democratic government. A single country was formed in which there was a single democracy with one person, one vote.
But the Palestinian people have not yet won their freedom. There has been no equivalent democratic settlement that recognises their full and equal humanity and political rights. There must also be a single free and democratic country with equal rights for all and one person, one vote in historic Palestine, from the river to the sea.
Of course in South Africa we have been betrayed by the ANC who have enriched themselves, repressed popular movements and struggles and left a devastated country with mass impoverishment, mass hunger and mass unemployment, including more than 60% youth unemployment. The ANC failed to deal with the structural basis of oppression. They did not even undertake meaningful land reform. South Africa shows both that the achievement of a single democratic state is possible, and that betrayal by new leaders and elites is also possible, with the result that it is essential for people to remain organised before, during and after liberation.
In South Africa, apartheid was defeated by a powerful trade union movement, a mass uprising of the people and the defeat of the apartheid military by the Cubans in Angola. A small but often brave minority of white people also opposed the system, weakening the white bloc in support of apartheid.
The different nature of oppression in Palestine and the different world situation means that a powerful trade union movement, a mass popular uprising and a defeat of the Israeli military by a socialist government is impossible. And while there are some Israelis who oppose the oppression of Palestinians, some with real courage, they are a very small minority and have not been able to weaken the fascist bloc in Israel.
Solidarity Between Our Struggles
There is a long history of solidarity between the South African and Palestinian liberation movements. The African National Congress (ANC), the Palestine Liberation Organisation, the Irish Republican Army and the Polisario Front all understand themselves as national liberation movements in a shared struggle against settler colonial oppression.
The ANC remains in solidarity with the Palestinian struggle, as do the vast majority of the South African people, including our movement and the trade unions.
Our movement was formed in Durban in 2005 by people living in shack settlements who had become tired of waiting for the promises of freedom to be fulfilled. We were told that apartheid had ended and that we were now free. But we continued to live without secure access to land, decent housing, water, electricity and sanitation.
We faced evictions and forced removals. Our homes were demolished. People were pushed away from the cities to places where there were no jobs and few opportunities to build a decent life. We discovered that the poor were still expected to know their place.
We were expected to accept decisions made by politicians and officials without participating in those decisions. We were treated as people who should be told what to do by others, such as the government, the ruling party and some NGOs, rather than as people who could think, organise and determine our own future.
When we insisted on our right to organise ourselves and speak for ourselves, we faced severe repression, including assassinations and police killings. Twenty-six lives have been lost in the course of our struggle.
Our movement rejected this. We insisted that the poor are human beings who can think for ourselves, speak for ourselves and organise ourselves. We have always said that the land and wealth of our country must be shared, that every person must count as a person, and that no one should be treated as if their life has less value than another.
We know what it means to have your home destroyed. We know what it means to be forced from land on which you have built your life. We know what it means to be confronted by armed men when you are simply demanding the right to live in dignity. We know what it is like to be tortured and to have our comrades murdered.
This is also why we understand the suffering of the Palestinian people. Our solidarity with Palestine is not based on the idea that our suffering is identical. It is based on the recognition that the oppression of another human being is a matter of concern to all of us. We are in solidarity with all oppressed people everywhere, from Palestine to the Congo, to migrants in the United States and our LGBTI comrades facing persecution in many countries.
We have faced severe repression from the ANC, and have been involved in a bitter struggle against them, our new oppressors. However, when the South African government brought its case against Israel at the International Court of Justice in December 2023, we offered our full support for this action.
We were proud when South African lawyers stood before the Court in The Hague and presented the case that Israel’s actions in Gaza violated the Genocide Convention. We regarded this as an important act of international solidarity and a defence of the humanity of the Palestinian people.
Any principled politics supports all measures to oppose oppression and we were clear that we must support this action of the ANC in government. However, it is very disappointing that South Africa continues to sell coal to Israel, is exploring for oil and gas in our oceans with an Israeli company and that ANC-aligned trade unions have not refused to load coal onto ships heading to Israel or refused to handle any ships heading to Israel as dockworkers in Namibia, Italy and elsewhere have done.
In 2025, South Africa exported approximately 1.8 million tonnes of coal to Israel. When the progressive government in Colombia stopped exporting coal to Israel, South Africa increased its shipments. This is very disappointing and must be clearly opposed.
The Problem of Race and Class in Palestine Solidarity Networks
The vast majority of South African people feel a deep kinship with the Palestinian people. This solidarity is rooted in our history. We know what it means to experience colonial domination, racial oppression, dispossession and the denial of human dignity. The Palestinian struggle has a particular meaning for South Africans because so many of us recognise aspects of our own history in the suffering of Palestinians.
But we must be honest about a serious failure in the solidarity networks in South Africa. This widespread solidarity felt by the majority of the South African people has not been effectively mobilised into the kind of powerful popular movement that could make South Africa a much stronger force in support of Palestine.
The reason for this is the failure to confront questions of race and class within the Palestine solidarity movement in South Africa itself. Poor and working-class African people have been systematically excluded from international connections and from participation in the decision-making in the wider solidarity movement. When we have been included, it has often been in subordinate, patronising and disrespectful ways. It is often assumed that our only job is to fill buses to make up the numbers at protests in which we have no role in planning. This is a serious political problem that has seriously weakened the solidarity movement.
If we want South Africa’s solidarity with Palestine to become a powerful popular force, the movement must be rooted much more deeply in the lives, struggles and organisations of the African working class and poor. We need to be engaged with respect and not just treated as people who must always be instructed by others, and often in very disrespectful ways. To be effective, the movement must be built through relationships of equality and mutual respect. Until these problems are confronted, the enormous potential of South African solidarity with the Palestinian people will remain largely unrealised.
The Power of International Solidarity
Our movement is very encouraged by the re-election of Lula in Brazil and by the recent political successes of the Democratic Socialists of America in the United States, including the election of Zohran Mamdani as mayor of New York City. But in many countries, particularly in Latin America, left-wing governments have lost power and the right has advanced. In Argentina, Chile, Bolivia and other countries, right-wing forces have made major gains.
South Africa is also experiencing a dramatic shift to the right. In our recent local government elections, the African National Congress suffered an extraordinary defeat, while right-wing parties made major gains. Some of these parties are openly hostile to migrants and have supported aggressive forms of nationalism and xenophobia. Some are also strongly in support of Israel.
In the current conjuncture Israel will not be defeated by states. It can, though, be defeated by the people of the world. In Aotearoa, the movement against the Springbok tour demonstrated that ordinary people could challenge a powerful system of oppression even when their own government was unwilling to take the necessary action.
We have been greatly encouraged by the solidarity that has been developed around the world, from the students in the United States to the dockworkers who, on 30 October this year, organised coordinated strikes and demonstrations at more than one hundred ports around the world against war, the transport of weapons and the militarisation of ports. Workers from Europe, North Africa and other parts of the world joined this mobilisation, with solidarity for Palestine at its centre.
The people of the world are called, with great urgency, to be in meaningful solidarity with the people of Palestine. This is a great mission of our generation and we cannot betray our responsibilities.
From the river to the sea, Palestine must be free.