Category Archives: Lyse Comins

Daily News: Blaze guts Kennedy Road

The politicians keep claiming that the conditions in Kennedy Road are bad because AbM refuses to accept removal and has therefore ‘stopped development’. They are lying. In fact AbM negotiated the move to Cornubia (for those who could not be accommodated in the upgrade) with the City and was able to negotiate both the upgrade and the move to Cornubia on the back of a mass struggle. Obed Mlaba forced offered Cornubia in 2006 after AbM marched on him demanding ‘land and housing’. The fact that there has been no progress in the development is the responsibility of the Municipality and not people that have demanded land and housing.

Click here to read ‘A Big Devil in the Jondolos: A report on Shack Fires’ by Matt Birkinshaw (2008).

http://www.iol.co.za/index.php?set_id=1&click_id=139&art_id=vn20100810123353558C817448&singlepage=1

Blaze guts Kennedy Road

August 10 2010 at 05:05PM

By Anelisa Khubeka and Lyse Comins

A raging fire which destroyed thousands of shacks at the Kennedy Road informal settlement in Durban has left about 1 100 people destitute.

The fire, which destroyed about 500 shacks, is believed to have started at 11pm on Sunday and continued to rage until early on Monday. It subsided at about 2am. Police are investigating a case of arson.

Fire department divisional commander, Alfred Newman, said firefighters arrived at about 11pm and fought the blaze for one-and-a-half hours before bringing it under control.

He said there were three minor injuries to residents, and two firemen had been taken to hospital for observation after suffering heat exhaustion.
Continues Below ?

“On arrival we found a large number of shacks alight. There were no people reported missing, but later during operations, when people were trying to evacuate, we had two people injured and someone fainted.

“We had five fire engines in attendance dealing with the fire. It was tough firefighting conditions for us. We had to fight that fire from three ends to knock it out. There was a south-westerly wind blowing and it made conditions unbearable for us, but there were no fatalities.”

Newman said a headcount at the community hall at 9am yesterday indicated that 1 100 people had been displaced.

“About 500 shacks were totally destroyed by fire. At this stage no one is giving us information on where the fire first started and what the cause is.

“There are visible illegal electrical connections in the settlement, but the cause of the fire at this stage is unknown.”

SAPS spokesperson Lieutenant-Colonel Vincent Mdunge said residents were treated for smoke inhalation and bruises and those who had lost their homes would be housed in community halls.

“People were treated for smoke inhalation and two minors were treated for bruises. We are investigating a suspected case of arson,” he said.

Yesterday, the air at the informal settlement was still heavy with the stench of the fire. However, this did not deter other residents, including children who spent most of the day outside, from lighting small fires to keep warm in the face of the windy cold front and nippy temperature.

Letha Madida, 25, has lived in the informal settlement since she was three and now lives there with her children aged five and three.

Madida said they had seen the fire on the far side of the shacks and had helped neighbours closer to the fire to move their belongings out of their homes, thinking that her home was safe and would not be reached by the flames.

“While we were moving out our neighbours’ belongings, a strong wind began, which caused the fire to get out of control and move towards our homes and by that time there was nothing we could do to save our belongings.”

Madida added that one of the most important items she had lost in the fire was her identity document.

She said at least she could explain to her employers that her uniform had been lost in the fire and get another one, but her life would come to a standstill without her ID.

“It is not that easy to replace identity document,” Madida said.

Unemployed residents who were due to collect their social grants this week were worried because they had lost their social grant cards in the blaze.

Most of the residents, who spoke to the Daily News on condition of anonymity, said they were sick and tired of reading in newspapers about how they did not want to move from Kennedy Road.

“We are tired of living under these circumstances and it is not true that we do not want to move,” said one resident.

“When I started living here in 1994 there weren’t this many people and if we had houses built for us then, we would not be in this predicament.”

Residents said that if they had electricity they would not have to live with the constant fires.

However, when they went to the municipality’s electricity department they were told that electricity was not installed in informal settlements.

Area councillor Yacoob Baig said there were more permanent relocation plans in place, but it was not clear when they would be implemented.

“At the moment we are looking at having tents put up for residents temporarily and others have been sleeping at the community hall, but I am going to be in meetings with officials and Nigel Gumede to decide on a more permanent solution,” he said.

Baig said there had been land identified in Kennedy Road to build houses for the informal settlement residents, and plans were in place to move some of them to about 35 000 houses in Cornubia in east Phoenix.

“By Wednesday (tomorrow) we will have the necessary department here to help residents replace their important documentation such as identity documents and social grant cards,” said Baig.

* This article was originally published on page 6 of Daily News on August 10, 2010

Daily News: War over Warwick rages on

War over Warwick rages on
Traders get third court order to open market

June 16, 2009 Edition 1

Lyse Comins

The war of Warwick Junction rages through Youth Day after traders obtained a third court order against eThekwini authorities.

The Early Morning Market traders secured another Durban High Court order yesterday forcing the municipality to open the market to legal traders tomorrow.

This came in the wake of another violent clash with Metro Police and a day of lost trade yesterday.

The Early Morning Market Traders’ Association chairman, Harry Ramlall, said his attorney was scheduled to meet the city’s legal counsel in court again today to clarify the dispute over legal and illegal traders in the market.

Dozens of traders waited all day yesterday outside the market, hoping it would be opened. Police fired rubber bullets, injuring four traders. Five traders were arrested on charges of alleged public violence.

“The city has given us the assurance that the market will be open. The order has been granted for the third time. The market will definitely be open on Wednesday morning,” said Ramlall.

“I will be at court at 9am (today) verifying the so-called illegal traders because they need to be legalised.

“It’s only fair if they have been there for a long time that they should be legal because the council has accepted rental from them.”

However, deputy mayor Logie Naidoo earlier said traders collectively owed the municipality hundreds of thousands of rands in rental arrears and many traders were illegal tenants.

Traders have opposed the demolition of the market to make way for a R400 million shopping mall.

Several “barrow boys”, who ferry fresh produce around the junction, told the Daily News they were hungry and worried about feeding their families. They worked for themselves, they said, and had lost their daily income of R100 to R200 a day since Friday.

Minority Front leader Amichand Rajbansi, who visited Warwick Junction yesterday, said he would call for a special motion to have the issue “re-debated” by the council. He said he would take the fight to the Human Rights Commission and the Equality Court.

“We were misled (by the council) that this (mall) would be developed over the railway line. Mike Sutcliffe calls this an apartheid structure and says he is concerned about the democratic majority. What does he mean by this?

“The saviour of our province is going to be SMMEs and the informal sector. We are going to take this issue very seriously. It is very strange that the leaders of this province are keeping silent,” Rajbansi said.

SAPS Captain Khepu Ndlovu said two women were injured yesterday when Metro Police fired rubber bullets at protesting traders, and two women were injured in falls. They were taken to hospital by ambulance.

Three men and two women were arrested and charged with public violence. Metro Police Superintendent Wiseman Mchunu said police had used “minimal force” to control the crowd.

eThekwini Municipality business support unit manager Philip Sithole said legal traders had been allowed access to the market but chose to stand in solidarity with the illegal traders.

SPCA chief inspector Dougie Du Plessis said traders had alerted him to the plight of 200 caged chickens inside the building. Eight chickens had died, but this was not from a lack of food and water.

Du Plessis said market managers had allowed some traders entry to tend their chickens, but not all the owners were present.

“They can’t stay cooped up here in small cages forever. Normally, they are sold within two days.

“We have been feeding and watering the birds at our own cost.

“Fruit and vegetables are going rotten but the municipality won’t allow traders in because if they do they will have another sit-in.

“It’s very sad because there are hungry people out there,” Du Plessis said.

Mercury: Anger over R400m mall plan

http://www.themercury.co.za/index.php?fArticleId=4990904

6 000 WARWICK JUNCTION INFORMAL TRADERS AFFECTED
Anger over R400m mall plan

May 21, 2009 Edition 1

Lyse Comins

TENSIONS heightened yesterday over the effects of a proposed R400 million shopping mall in Durban’s bustling Warwick Junction, as city officials and academics met representatives of 6 000 angry informal traders.

The traders, who fear the development will destroy their businesses, threatened to march to the city hall next Tuesday to protest against the development and what they say is a lack of consultation with traders and a “failure to follow the tender process”.

An intense two-hour debate was hosted by the Democracy Development Programme in a packed Durban University of Technology’s city campus hall.

Attended by about 600 informal traders, University of KwaZulu-Natal development studies unit researcher Caroline Skinner, Deputy Mayor Logie Naidoo, and Professor Rodney Harber of UKZN’s department of architecture, the debate was vigorous and marked by angry outbursts and singing. Representatives from the private developer, Warwick Wall Consortium, were not present.

Naidoo explained the aim of the development was to upgrade and rejuvenate an area affected by urban decay. The city was investing R100 million towards the first phase of the development, which had to be completed by June 1 next year in time for 2010 World Cup. The development includes road and freeway realignments, a more logical positioning of taxi ranks and the creation of a mall with banking and retail facilities.

However, informal traders blew on vuvuzelas and stood to dance and shout slogans in isiZulu like “down with capitalism” and “leave the poor alone” to express their anger and discontent at Naidoo’s official response to their concerns.

International street traders’ organisation StreetNet was present with 25 international delegates from Malawi, Zimbabwe, Niger, Uganda, Nepal and the United states.

Warwick Market Traders Association chairman Harry Ramlall and Warwick Precinct Plan Stakeholders Forum chairman Roothren Moodley represented informal traders.

Ramlall said traders had not been consulted about the development, which would ruin their livelihood if they were forced out of the area.

Traders have been given notice to vacate the Early Morning Market and move to a building in Alice Street by May 31.

Naidoo said almost 500 000 commuters travelled daily through the junction, generating an estimated R1 billion in revenue for the mix of formal and informal traders. However, informal traders fear the mall has been designed to redirect commuters’ foot traffic away from their stalls and into the shopping mall and that there will be no space for them despite the city’s repeated promises to include them.

Ramlall said the city had presented the development plan to traders as a fait accompli at a meeting on February 18.

“We were told there would be workshops telling us exactly what is going on but all we had was a meeting with city manager Michael Sutcliffe where we were only asked, what are our requirements,” he said.

“It was presented to us as a proposal but we could read between the lines it was not a proposal; it was presented as what we are going to do – close the market and shut it down and relocate us to the materials management building. But there was no viability study done,” Ramlall said.

An unidentified trader asked, to loud applause by participants, why a “first world” mall was being imposed on “third world people” who do not care to visit malls like the Pavilion and Gateway.

“We have approximately eight malls within a 10km radius around the city; why put up another mall?” asked Ramlall.

He said traders were not against the development but they want to be incorporated into a new development.

Cosatu representative Mthokozisi Khuboni announced that informal traders, dissatisfied with the city’s response, would stage a protest march to the city hall next Tuesday.

Mercury: Traders feel threatened by development

http://www.themercury.co.za/index.php?fArticleId=4988935

Traders feel threatened by development

May 20, 2009 Edition 1

Lyse Comins

Inanda woman Ntombikayise Gagayi, 44, works diligently in her makeshift kitchen in Durban’s bustling Warwick Junction, where she cooks bovine heads for a living.

These she sells to her customers – a fraction of the estimated 460 000 commuters that travel daily through this busy intersection of traffic, train station, taxi ranks and bus terminals.

Gagayi, whose husband was killed in political violence in the early 1990s, depends on this passing trade to support her 10 children. She is one of 30 widows who sell bovine heads and other plated food at the junction’s open-air food stalls.

The women traders are among an estimated 6 000 people who depend on Warwick Junction’s brisk informal trade, which filters desperately needed income to townships and far-flung, poverty-stricken rural areas such as Umkomaas, Ndwedwe and Inanda.

In communities hard-hit by HIV/Aids, traders’ daily takings support up to 25 people. About 460 000 commuters travel daily through the area generating R1 billion in turnover for the existing mix of formal and informal traders.

But now traders fear that the eThekwini Municipality and Umhlanga-based developer, Isolenu, which forms part of the Warwick Mall consortium that is behind the proposed new R400 million shopping mall, will devastate their businesses by redirecting commuters to the mall, away from their street stalls, which will be moved to designated areas.

Bovine-head cookers like Gagayi will be moved to the nearby English Market to make way for the mall’s franchised fast-food court. And 673 traders in the early morning market building, the proposed site of the mall, have been notified to vacate by May 31.

The development includes a 30 000 square metre mall and taxi rank on the building’s top level to cater for south-bound taxis. The mall will be linked by walkways and bridges to the train station and bus rank and to redeveloped ranks for west-and north-bound taxis. The new freeway flyovers are already under construction and the new taxi rank are planned for completion in 2010.

Isolenu Group Holdings CEO Carlos Correia said he was surprised by traders’ fears and defended the development, saying it would incorporate informal traders and create 680 permanent jobs and a number of part-time jobs.

He said Spar would be the anchor tenant with a 70% national profile of tenants including FNB, Nedbank, Standard Bank, Jet, Foschini, Truworths, African Bank, the Post Office, Eskom Financial Services and several fast-food outlets.

However, the development in its present form has been widely opposed by informal traders’ associations who claim the city has sidelined them, while NGOs and the KwaZulu-Natal Institute of Architects have also opposed it.

In formal comments, the development proposal process has been labelled “flawed” and lacking due process regarding tendering and public consultation with traders and ratepayers. Richard Dobson of NGO Asiye Tafuleni said the development had been presented to traders as a fait accompli on February 18 without any real interaction.

KZN Institute of Architects’ president Miles Pennington said: “We consider the process flawed owing to the lack of any recognition of the strategic plan for the area, adherence to this plan, public consultation with current users of the site, local developers and ratepayers, due process in respect of procuring tenders for projects such as these, poor conceptualisation of the project… We believe this has been exacerbated by the need to complete the project in a timeframe that cannot be realistically met.

“We consider the ‘deal’ to be financially prejudicial to ratepayers, who are funding a significant proportion. This comment is made given the lack of sufficient evidence to the contrary. We would like to see a detailed viability study,” Pennington said.

The eThekweni Municipality Strategic Projects Unit and 2010 Programme head, Julie-May Ellingson, and city manager Michael Sutcliffe declined to comment.

“We remain involved in discussions on this matter as per council’s resolutions with directly concerned parties and I do not think it appropriate to comment on hearsay and opinions through the media,” Sutcliffe said.

However, Correira said the consortium had air rights for the space connecting the market with the train station, which was why the city had started talking to his company about developing the mall.

“We have all our EIA approvals which date back to 2007. We were going to develop the station first with retail outlets. I can only assume the city followed all its council processes. It went to the city in September last year where there was a council resolution taken and in February the process of the Municipal Financial Act was met.

“There were various objections and at the end of April we were informed that we can carry on with our development,” Correia said.

Warwick Market Traders’ Association chairman Harry Ramlall, a third-generation trader in the listed 99-year-old Early Morning Market building, said traders had reported the matter to Amafa and were seeking legal advice regarding their proposed move to a building in nearby Alice street.

“We have been here for 99 years. Some of us are fourth-generation traders. They want to relocate us to the materials management building but my concern is we don’t even know if it is a viable proposition.

“We need to go to a place where we can do business. The building has been lying vacant for a number of years and there are no people moving through there. If something goes wrong someone has to be held accountable,” Ramlall said.

Apart from loss of trade, Ramlall said he feared not all traders, who directly and indirectly employed about 3 000 people and 500 barrow pushers who take produce to street traders, would be accommodated at the new site.

However, Correia said he believed the traders had been consulted. “We are surprised to hear these kinds of comments. They (traders) seemed to take a strong view to keep the market, but the city had strong views that the market has been problematic for many years with rental issues and with conditions people are trading in,” Correira said.

Jabulani Ntsele chairman of the Eye Traders’ Association, Sisonke Alliance, said traders were concerned that traders consulting with the city had been coerced by promises of small tenders to accept the development and were not representing the community’s interests. He said traders had asked Cosatu and the South African Communist Party to assist and were planning a protest march.

“There is a big clash and the traders are going to start rising up because they are scared they are going to lose their jobs. They are destroying the livelihood of the people.

“Even to say people will get places to trade inside… we have never seen any mall where street traders are allowed to trade inside or outside, and we don’t have any agreement on paper to say that we can trade in the mall,” Ntsele said.

Correia said in terms of the council’s decision the developer had to accommodate 150 street traders in a new public square at its own cost and another 130 traders with permits would be moved at the city’s expense. He said various consultations had taken place. “We met every condition of the city. We have to provide lock-up areas and lighting for them. Regarding the bovine cookers my understanding is there is a big health issue with where they are now,” Correia said.

Ngoneni Khawula, 62, who represents vegetable sellers and food cookers like Gagayi, said the wrangle was heartbreaking.

“It’s our only source of income and the majority of traders are elderly women and widows. It’s like we are being thrown into the middle of a thick bush where there is no passing trade,” Khawula said.

UKZN School of Development Studies researcher Caroline Skinner called the wrangle between informal traders, the city and its developers as a battle for business between the formal economy, which would take profits out of the local economy, and the informal economy, which provides an income for KwaZulu-Natal’s poorest people.

Meanwhile, the Democracy Development Programme will be hosting a public discussion to debate the development and provide a platform for traders and the public to air their views. The meeting is taking place at the Durban University of Technology’s city campus at noon today.