Category Archives: Mohammed Allie

BBC: Cape Town squatters battle plans for Muslim hotel

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-africa-11517334

Cape Town squatters battle plans for Muslim hotel

The BBC’s Mohammed Allie reports on a historic disused quarry, the last piece of vacant urban space on the edge of Cape Town’s central business district, which has become the subject of a dispute between 150 squatters who live there and one of South Africa’s oldest mosques that wants to build a Muslim-friendly hotel on the land.

Nestled in the quarry above Cape Town, the informal settlement known as the Kraal has sweeping views of South Africa’s iconic Table Mountain and the city’s trendy Waterfront and harbour areas.

The area, first occupied by squatters in the early 1980s, has grown to accommodate 24 shacks housing 150 people, including many children.
Continue reading the main story

In recent months, several newcomers have erected plastic and corrugated iron dwellings in a narrow slit of ground about 100m away from the main camp.

The mosque authorities, led by Imam Moutie Saban, have complained about rising crime in the area. Tourists have been robbed and cars and houses broken into.

The mosque’s sound system has been stolen and toilet facilities smeared with faeces.

The city’s law enforcement authorities say the Kraal has been used as a hideout by criminals escaping police.

“Yes, we have had a criminal element and drug dealers but they have been arrested and are now in prison,” says Kraal community leader Kenny Prins.
Infuriated

Imam Saban wants the area upgraded and has applied to the city council, which owns the land, to build a no-alcohol hotel, along with a business centre and a heritage centre on ground, which adjoins the back part of the historic Jameah mosque.

Kenny Prins Community leader Kenny Prins says squatter residents must be given proper housing

The mosque, which was built in 1790 on land provided by the British colonial authorities, was the first to perform Friday congregational prayers in South Africa.

The mosque has already bought the house next door and wants to extend prayer facilities and the toilet block to accommodate the increasing number of worshippers.

Belinda Walker, city councillor for the area, confirmed receiving an unsolicited application to develop the land from Imam Saban and his son Wafeeq.

“Last year Imam Saban and his son came to see me about their proposal to extend the mosque. They proposed a development on the site of the quarry which would cross-subsidise their upgrade because of the high cost of the renovation.
Continue reading the main story

“They said funding was available to build a Muslim-friendly hotel which would serve no alcohol and would meet the dietary needs of Muslim visitors. It would also allow for a separate swimming pool for females,” says Ms Walker.

But the proposal has infuriated the Kraal community, as well as local residents represented by the Bo Kaap Civic Association.

“It’s against the scripture of all religions to evict poor people from their homes, so we need to ensure the residents of the Kraal have access to decent housing before moving them from the site,” says Osman Shabodien, chair of the association.

“The area has huge historical and heritage significance, so whatever we eventually decide to do, it will have to be carefully planned and we need to consult with the surrounding community.

“Any development has to benefit the entire community and not just a few individuals,” says Mr Shabodien.

Solid rock

Mr Prins says residents of the informal settlement need to be given proper housing before there can be any thought of developing the land.

Many of the Kraal residents grew up in the area and will not accept being moved to the council’s Blikkiesdorp resettlement camp, some 28km (18 miles) away.
Jameah mosque Mosque authorities have complained about rising crime in the area

“Our children attend school in the area, so you can’t just uproot them,” says Mr Prins.

Kraal resident Mareldia Abrahams, a 54-year-old mother of four, says she would be prepared to move should the council provide her with a formal house.

“I have been on the council’s waiting list for 17 years but to this day I’m still waiting for my house,” says Ms Abrahams.

According to Ms Walker, there are no immediate plans for the land as a long consultation process still has to be followed.

“We are currently busy with a heritage study which will inform us what sort of development is suitable for the ground. We then need to advertise the development proposals for public comment so the entire process will take at least a year,” she says.

Ms Walker ruled out providing formal housing on the land for Kraal residents.

“The area is situated on solid rock, which means it will be difficult and very expensive to lay underground sewerage and water connection pipes for council-subsidised housing. There are also up to 250 informal settlements in Cape Town that need our attention,” she says.

BBC: South Africans fight eviction for World Cup car park

http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/world/africa/10205455.stm

by Mohammed Allie BBC News, Cape Town

For six families living in derelict changing rooms next to one of South Africa’s official training venues in Cape Town, the prospect of the football World Cup has turned from a dream to a nightmare.

The families who comprise 24 people, half of them children, are facing eviction to make space for the parking area next to the Athlone Stadium which has been upgraded to the tune of 406m rand ($53m, £36m) to bring it up to Fifa standards.

The upgrade includes a brand new pitch, three new grandstands, VIP suites and improved player facilities.

The tenacity of the families, who have mounted a legal challenge with the help of the Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign, has bought them time as Cape Town’s City Council has been ordered by a local magistrate’s court to find suitable alternative accommodation before the changing room can be demolished.

Some of the families have been living in the changing rooms for as long as 11 years, as the city’s acute housing shortage, which is said to number 410,000 units, has driven desperate people to live rough in the poorer parts of Cape Town.

Football blackout

Following the closure of an AstroTurf hockey complex and the subsequent departure of non-governmental organisations (NGOs) who used the changing rooms, the current occupants divided the facility into six tiny cement-floored rooms, one for each family.

They all share two toilets and two taps. They have had no electricity since the council cut off the power two years ago.

One of the changing room residents Lewellyn Wilters said he “cried with joy” when he first heard six years ago that South Africa would host the World Cup.

“I was overjoyed when I heard that Athlone would be upgraded. I thought it would bring good things for all of us in this area, which is desperately in need of development,” he said.

“Now I’m crying again. I’m going to lose my home because of the World Cup, and what makes it worse is that we are being told that we must move for a parking lot.”

The car park is now being built around them.

“We don’t want the World Cup because these people [Fifa] come with their own rules and in the end it’s the locals that suffer,” Mr Wilters said.

“We don’t even have electricity in here, so we won’t be able to watch the games on television.

“What’s the use of supporting Bafana [the South African team] when we can’t watch them.”

As a football-lover Mr Wilters is, however, still hoping that Brazil will train in Cape Town during the course of the month-long tournament, and is prepared to pay to watch them practise.

“Then I would say ‘thank you’ the World Cup did something for us. But at the back of my mind the eviction is still in my mind because I could be out on the street when it’s all over.”

But Blamo Brooks, the council’s area manager for sport and recreation, is unrepentant about the planned eviction, saying the facility is not fit for human habitation.

“This venue was built as a changing] room to serve hockey and soccer players,” he said.

“The living space is not properly partitioned to allow for household occupancy. The ablution facilities, the water and electricity provision is not suitable for occupancy.

“It certainly is not suitable to house six families – it’s an undesirable situation for people to live under such conditions.”

Next to the changing room, a semi-detached cottage which was built in the 1930s to house army officers, has already been demolished.

Architectural heritage

Yaseen Watson, 70, who lived in one of the cottages, was more fortunate than the six families since he was offered alternative accommodation across the road.

However, he regrets that the home in which he lived since 1966 was demolished to make way for the parking area.

“It was very sad, from the day the council came to me and said they wanted to move me to make way for a parking area.

“After all, 43 years is a long time. It was very hard for me, the house has so many memories – all 10 of my children were born and grew up there.”

Ashraf Cassiem, co-ordinator for the Western Cape Anti-Eviction Campaign in Cape Town, believes the council should have restored the house given its age because it was part of the area’s heritage, rather than knocking it down.

Mr Brooks disagrees, saying: “The community has not been impoverished by the demolition of the two cottages and neither have the occupants been disadvantaged. On the contrary, they are better off as they are now living in two separate cottages which are bigger than the ones they lived in before.”

Meanwhile, the council has unveiled an extensive plan to get homeless people off the street leading up to the World Cup and Cape Town’s notoriously harsh winter season.

Working closely with NGOs, the city plans to accommodate and employ hundreds of homeless men, women and children, as well as reunite them with their families.

Armed with more than 1,000 disposable razors, 6,000 bars of soap, 6,000 toothbrushes, 4,000 tubes of toothpaste and 1,000 blankets, the city is also hoping to ensure the people are clean and well-groomed for the duration of the programme.

It will also create 600 temporary jobs to assist vulnerable people with the reintegration process, paying them 40 rand ($5.20, £3.60) a shift.